The Firm Leaders Summit runs November 16 to 18. Three days for recruiting firm owners and leaders: hiring and training recruiters, BD, growth, and being the rainmaker for your firm. Live sessions are free. Register: https://firm-leaders-and-owners-recruiting-summit-2026.heysummit.com/
This episode is brought to you by Atlas, the CRMx that captures every call, email, and message automatically and tells you the next move. https://recruitwithatlas.com/
Also brought to you by Well Oiled Machine. Greg Fischer helps recruiting firms hire proven offshore recruiters and sourcers you pay directly, no middleman. https://www.welloiledmachine.co/
Anthony Vennare never planned to run a recruiting firm. He was making introductions for free, about 30 in a year, until a friend in recruiting told him he was an idiot. That was a recruiting business, and he was giving every fee away. Today that firm is on pace for $5 million in its second year, with one founder, two recruiters, an ops manager, and zero outbound BD.
Anthony is one of the founders of Fitt, best known for Fitt Insider, the health and wellness industry publication. He breaks down how years of giving value away, through a free job board, a newsletter founders actually read, and an audience of roughly 700,000 people as he tells it, turned a simple form on the website into 10 searches in two weeks. Then he walks through the first 48 hours after a form fill, why year one was all contingent and year two is about half retained, the care package every placed candidate gets, and why he believes recruiting is a trust game, not a transaction.
He is also honest about what he got wrong, from saying yes to every client to underpricing early, and shares what a solo recruiter or boutique without a media company should build first.
CHAPTERS
0:00 Intro
3:33 2 recruiters, zero outbound, a $5M pace
4:41 What recruiting insiders can’t see
6:24 Add value all day, no pay-to-play
8:08 “You’re an idiot. That’s recruiting.”
8:21 Who is Anthony Vennare?
9:34 What owning a gym taught him
10:13 The book behind everything: Crush It!
11:38 Building companies with his brother
13:33 Why health comes first
14:35 The free job board that became a recruiting firm
16:36 The thesis that made them say yes
18:35 Paying a recruiter to teach them the business
20:06 10 searches in 2 weeks
20:27 What if the first recruiter hire failed?
22:25 What recruiters undervalue
23:49 The post-placement care package
24:29 Building a talent network people answer
26:15 What a traditional firm can steal
27:34 Throw the event, don’t buy the booth
29:01 Why talent beats bigger businesses on profit
31:16 How few people know they recruit
32:52 What other firm owners taught him
34:31 The first 48 hours after a form fill
37:43 Contingent, retained, and a hybrid model
38:49 “No way”: how lean they run
39:29 Placing leaders who are already leaving
41:42 Using his LinkedIn for outreach
42:55 What a solo recruiter should build first
47:02 How they fund it without investors
49:15 Quickfire: books and tech
51:05 What he’d tell himself 2 years ago
51:53 The biggest mistake: saying yes to every client
53:48 Giving value vs. charging your worth
54:49 The question nobody asks him
57:14 Why the people make it work
58:22 How to connect with Anthony
59:32 Final thoughts
LINKS
📅 Firm Leaders Summit (Nov 16 to 18): https://firm-leaders-and-owners-recruiting-summit-2026.heysummit.com/
⚡ Atlas: https://recruitwithatlas.com/
🌎 Well Oiled Machine (Greg Fischer): https://www.welloiledmachine.co/
👤 Anthony Vennare on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/vennare/
📰 Fitt Insider: https://insider.fitt.co/
💼 Fitt Talent: https://talent.fitt.co/
🤝 Elite Recruiter Community: https://elite-recruiters.circle.so/checkout/elite-recruiter-community
📬 Newsletter: https://eliterecruiterpodcast.beehiiv.com/subscribe