Thank you for over 212K Downloads in 2025 between Spotify and Apple Podcast
Nov. 16, 2026

$5M Pace, 2nd Year. 1 Founder, 2 Recruiters, 100% Inbound

$5M Pace, 2nd Year. 1 Founder, 2 Recruiters, 100% Inbound
$5M Pace, 2nd Year. 1 Founder, 2 Recruiters, 100% Inbound
The Elite Recruiter Podcast
$5M Pace, 2nd Year. 1 Founder, 2 Recruiters, 100% Inbound

Key Takeaways

  • Anthony Vennare transitioned into the recruiting space organically by realizing that making free industry introductions was actually a monetizable recruiting service.
  • Fitt Talent scaled to a $5 million pace in its second year with just one founder, two recruiters, and an operations manager entirely through 100% inbound lead generation.
  • The inbound strategy relies heavily on owned media assets, including a niche newsletter, a free job board, and a simple website form that captures immediate client interest.
  • The firm evolved its business model from strictly contingent searches in year one to a hybrid approach featuring roughly half retained searches and flat monthly fees combined with per-hire fees.
  • Building deep post-placement relationships through thoughtful gifts and ongoing newsletter touchpoints transforms single hires into long-term industry partners.

The Firm Leaders Summit runs November 16 to 18. Three days built for recruiting firm owners and leaders: hiring and training recruiters, BD, growth, and being the rainmaker for your firm. Live sessions are free. Register now: https://firm-leaders-and-owners-recruiting-summit-2026.heysummit.com/

This episode is brought to you by Atlas, the CRMx that captures every call, email, and message automatically and tells you the next move. https://recruitwithatlas.com/

Also brought to you by Well Oiled Machine. Greg Fischer helps recruiting firms hire proven offshore recruiters and sourcers you pay directly, no middleman. https://www.welloiledmachine.co/

Anthony Vennare never set out to run a recruiting firm. He was making introductions for free, about 30 of them in a year, as he tells it, until a friend in the industry told him he was an idiot. That was recruiting, and he was leaving the money on the table.

Today, the recruiting firm he stood up is on pace for $5 million in its second year. One founder, two recruiters, an ops manager, and 100% inbound. No outbound BD.

Anthony is one of the founders of Fitt, best known for Fitt Insider, the health and wellness industry publication. The group also runs a PR firm, a consulting arm, an investment fund, events, Femtech Insider, Wellworthy, and Fitt Talent. In this episode he breaks down how a media company that refused to sell pay-to-play ads became a recruiting business: a free job board, a newsletter founders actually read, and a simple form on the website that brought in 10 searches in two weeks.

Benjamin and Anthony get tactical. What happens in the first 48 hours after someone fills out that form, starting with an email from Anthony within minutes and a call that is never a pitch. Why year one was strictly contingent and year two is roughly half retained, plus a hybrid model of a flat monthly fee and a fee per hire. How a talent network built from an enriched newsletter list, a job board, and LinkedIn lets the team tell clients that everyone who should see a role actually saw it. And why the relationship doesn’t end when the search does, with hoodies, gym bags, notebooks, and his newsletter in their inbox twice a week.

He is also honest about what he got wrong. Saying yes to every client who filled out the form burned his team’s time, and staying in stealth means only a small slice of his own audience knows the firm exists. His advice for recruiters without a media company: partner with someone who already has a voice in your niche, throw the event instead of buying the booth, and put your acquisition budget into owned assets instead of more BD hires.

If you have been told recruiting is a numbers game, this episode makes the case that it is a trust game, and shows what winning it looks like.

What You’ll Learn:

  • How free introductions became a recruiting firm on pace for $5M in year two
  • Why Fitt made its job board free, and what that unlocked
  • The inbound process, from form fill to signed agreement
  • How to build a talent network people actually respond to
  • The post-placement playbook that turns every hire into a long-term relationship
  • Why the firm moved from all contingent to half retained
  • What a solo recruiter or boutique should build first without a media company

Links:

📅 Firm Leaders Summit (Nov 16 to 18): https://firm-leaders-and-owners-recruiting-summit-2026.heysummit.com/

⚡ Atlas: https://recruitwithatlas.com/

🌎 Well Oiled Machine (Greg Fischer): https://www.welloiledmachine.co/

👤 Anthony Vennare on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/vennare/

📰 Fitt Insider: https://insider.fitt.co/

💼 Fitt Talent: https://talent.fitt.co/

🤝 Elite Recruiter Community: https://elite-recruiters.circle.so/checkout/elite-recruiter-community

📬 Newsletter: https://eliterecruiterpodcast.beehiiv.com/subscribe

Frequently Asked Questions

Who is Anthony Vennare?

Anthony Vennare is a founder of Fitt and Fitt Insider, a prominent health and wellness industry publication, who successfully launched and scaled a high-growth recruiting firm.

How did Fitt Talent achieve 100% inbound recruiting growth?

The firm leveraged its existing media footprint, including a popular industry newsletter and a free job board, driving clients to a simple website inquiry form without doing any outbound business development.

What is the fee structure of Anthony Vennare's recruiting firm?

After starting strictly contingent in year one, the firm transitioned to a model that is roughly half retained, utilizing a hybrid structure of a flat monthly fee plus a fee per hire.

What advice does Anthony Vennare give to recruiters without a media company?

He advises recruiters to partner with someone who already has an established voice in their niche, host industry events instead of just buying booths, and invest acquisition budgets into owned assets rather than hiring more business development staff.

Related to this Episode

How to Build an Inbound Recruiting Agency Without Cold Outreach

Building an inbound recruiting agency requires replacing cold outbound business development with owned media assets like newsletters, free job boards, and industry trust. By offering upfront value and capturing inbound form fills, boutique firms can…