How To Build A Multi-Million-Dollar Recruiting Firm From Zero
Key Takeaways
- Building a recruiting firm from scratch requires a resilient mindset, especially when navigating unexpected market downturns like the COVID-19 pandemic.
- Strategic hiring during quiet market periods, rather than furloughs, can position a recruiting agency to scale rapidly once the economy recovers.
- The human touch remains the primary differentiator for elite recruiters, separating them from automated and replaceable services.
- Targeted, sniper-like recruiting efforts are significantly more effective for quality placements than high-volume, generic outreach strategies.
- Maintaining a physical, collaborative environment where teams work shoulder-to-shoulder provides a distinct competitive advantage over fully remote agencies.
- Success in building a recruiting firm is rooted in consistently doing the foundational reps, regardless of how many years of experience you have in the industry.
The AI Recruiting Summit 2026 is happening now through July 20th, and registration is free for every live session. Recruiting engineers, operators, and recruiters actually running AI on their desks are showing what is working behind the scenes. Do not miss it. Register here: https://ai-recruiting-summit-2026.heysummit.com/
This episode is brought to you by Atlas. The resume never tells the full story, and most of what candidates share ends up buried in notes and forgotten. Atlas is the AI first recruitment platform built to eliminate admin. It captures every conversation automatically, and with MagicSearch you can ask things like who mentioned they are open to relocating and pull the answer from your entire database instantly. Atlas customers have reported over 40% EBITDA growth and over 80% increase in monthly billings after adopting the platform. Unlock your exclusive listener offer here: https://recruitwithatlas.com/
Holly Dary spent nearly 20 years becoming everything she set out to be at a large global staffing firm. She oversaw eight markets, built teams that produced, and made very good money. Then she hit her 20 year mark and a question she could not shake. Keep doing the same thing on repeat until retirement, or bet on herself and build something of her own.
She chose the second act. At the end of 2019 she launched Tarbos Talent in Austin, put all of her chips in the middle of the table as the sole provider for her family, and started making placements right away. Then, three months in, COVID shut everything down. Every job order died. Offers were rescinded. For a brand new firm with a database built from nothing, it should have been the end.
Instead she doubled down. While competitors furloughed and let go of long time producers, Holly hired the best of them. She built her tech stack and her database through the quiet months, got her team back in the office the moment Texas allowed it, and came out of the shutdown twice as strong. From zero she has built a team of 26 across two offices in Austin and Houston, in a business where most firms take 12 to 18 months just to turn a profit. Tarbos was profitable inside of two.
None of that is the most remarkable thing she has survived. Fifteen years ago, when her daughter had just turned one, Holly was diagnosed with AML leukemia and told to get to the hospital within 30 minutes. She was not scared. She was furious that anything might take her from her kids, and she carried the same positive mindset that runs her business straight through treatment. Her oncologist later told her that her attitude was half the reason she made it.
In this conversation Holly breaks down how she builds firms that win. Why the human touch is what separates an elite recruiter from a replaceable one. Why she recruits like a sniper instead of blasting 500 people at once. Why speed and sitting shoulder to shoulder with her team is a real advantage in a remote world. And why, after 26 years, doing the reps is still the whole game.
If there is a quiet voice in the back of your head telling you it is time for your own second act, this is the episode.
Connect with Holly Dary on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/holly-dary-aba2952/
Listen to the full episode:
🎯 Join the Elite Recruiter Community: https://elite-recruiters.circle.so/checkout/elite-recruiter-community
📩 Get the newsletter: https://eliterecruiterpodcast.beehiiv.com/subscribe
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best approach to building a recruiting firm from zero?
Building a recruiting firm starts with betting on yourself and maintaining a resilient mindset, focusing on high-quality, targeted placements rather than high-volume outreach.
How can I scale my staffing agency during an economic downturn?
Instead of cutting staff, use economic lulls to invest in your tech stack, strengthen your database, and strategically hire top-tier talent so you are ready to scale immediately when the market rebounds.
Why is the human touch important when building a recruiting firm?
While automation is useful, the human touch is what builds deep relationships and provides the nuance necessary to make elite placements that automated systems cannot replicate.
